Decisions - BC Hospital Appeal Board

Preliminary and Final Decisions

Dr. Malvinder Hoonjan v. Interior Health Authority

POST DECISION ORDER

RE: IMPLEMENTATION

File:
https://www.bchab.ca/app/uploads/sites/781/2023/09/HAB-HA-20-A003c.pdf

Date:
September 13, 2023

Act:

Hospital Act

File Number(s):
HAB-HA-20-A003

Decision Number(s):
HAB-HA-20-A003(c)
Katherine Puchala v. Northern Health Authority

[POST-DECISION APPLICATION TO VARY ORDER – Granted in Part]

File:
https://www.bchab.ca/app/uploads/sites/781/2023/08/HAB-HA-20-A001d.pdf

Date:
March 15, 2023

Act:

Hospital Act

File Number(s):
HAB-HA-20-A001

Decision Number(s):
HAB-HA-20-A001(d)
Dr. Christopher McCollister v. Vancouver Island Health Authority

[STAY APPLICATION – DENIED]

File:
https://www.bchab.ca/app/uploads/sites/781/2023/07/HAB-HA-22-A002a.pdf

Date:
February 3, 2023

Act:

Hospital Act

File Number(s):
HAB-HA-22-A002

Decision Number(s):
HAB-HA-22-A002(a)
Dr. Malvinder Hoonjan v. Interior Health Authority

[FINAL DECISION – APPEAL ALLOWED]

File:
https://www.bchab.ca/app/uploads/sites/781/2023/07/HAB-HA-20-A003b.pdf

Date:
December 7, 2022

Act:

Hospital Act

File Number(s):
HAB-HA-20-A003

Decision Number(s):
HAB-HA-20-A003(b)
Dr. Saraswathi Vedam v. Provincial Health Services Authority

[APPLICATION FOR INTERIM STAY – GRANTED; CORRIGENDUM ADDED]

File:
https://www.bchab.ca/app/uploads/sites/781/2023/07/HAB-HA-22-A001a_corrigendum.pdf

Date:
July 22, 2022

Act:

Hospital Act

File Number(s):
HAB-HA-22-A001

Decision Number(s):
HAB-HA-22-A001(a)
Katherine Puchala v. Northern Health Authority

FINAL DECISION

APPEAL ALLOWED

File:
https://www.bchab.ca/app/uploads/sites/781/2022/03/HAB-HA-20-A001c-1.pdf

Date:
March 16, 2022

Act:

Hospital Act

File Number(s):
HAB-HA-20-A001

Decision Number(s):
HAB-HA-20-A001(c)
Dr. Malvinder Hoonjan v. Interior Health Authority

APPLICATION FOR DOCUMENT PRODUCTION

File:
https://www.bchab.ca/app/uploads/sites/781/2022/03/HAB-HA-20-A003a-1.pdf

Date:
February 15, 2022

Act:

Hospital Act

File Number(s):
HAB-HA-20-A003

Decision Number(s):
HAB-HA-20-A003(a)
Katherine Puchala v. Northern Health Authority

APPLICATION FOR ADJOURNMENT

HEARING ADJOURNED

File:
https://www.bchab.ca/app/uploads/sites/781/2021/03/HAB-HA-20-A001b-1.pdf

Date:
February 24, 2021

Act:

Hospital Act

File Number(s):
HAB-HA-20-A001

Decision Number(s):
HAB-HA-20-A001(b)
Dr. Francis McCormack v. Island Health Authority

PRELIMINARY APPLICATIONS

GRANTED IN PART

Date:
February 5, 2021

Act:

Hospital Act

File Number(s):
2019-HA-001

Decision Number(s):
2019-HA-001(a)
Katherine Puchala v. Northern Health Authority

PRELIMINARY DECISION

APPLICATIONS DISMISSED

File:
https://www.bchab.ca/app/uploads/sites/781/2021/02/HAB-HA-20-A001a-1.pdf

Date:
February 2, 2021

Act:

Hospital Act

File Number(s):
HAB-HA-20-A001

Decision Number(s):
HAB-HA-20-A001(a)
Dr. Campbell v. Provincial Health Services Authority

FINAL DECISION

File:
https://www.bchab.ca/app/uploads/sites/781/2020/09/2018ha002f.pdf

Date:
August 20, 2020

Act:

Hospital Act

File Number(s):
2018-HA-002

Decision Number(s):
2018-HA-002(f)
Dr. Andrew Campbell v. Provincial Health Services Authority

APPLICATION FOR INTERIM INJUCTIVE RELIEF

DISMISSED

File:
https://www.bchab.ca/app/uploads/sites/781/2020/07/2018ha002d.pdf

Date:
July 11, 2019

Act:

Hospital Act

File Number(s):
2018-HA-002

Decision Number(s):
2018-HA-002(d)
Dr. David Kates v. Interior Health Authority

PRELIMINARY DECISION

File:
https://www.bchab.ca/app/uploads/sites/781/2020/07/2015ha002_clarification_ruling.pdf

Date:
December 20, 2018

Act:

Hospital Act

File Number(s):
2015-HA-002
Dr. Andrew Campbell v. Provincial Health Services Authority

PRELIMINARY DECISION ON STAY APPLICATION

DISMISSED

File:
https://www.bchab.ca/app/uploads/sites/781/2020/07/2018ha002b.pdf

Date:
November 30, 2018

Act:

Hospital Act

File Number(s):
2018-HA-002

Decision Number(s):
2018-HA-002(b)
Margaret Guillen v. Island Health Authority

PRELIMINARY DECISION

File:
https://www.bchab.ca/app/uploads/sites/781/2020/07/2017ha001b.pdf

Date:
November 16, 2018

Act:

Hospital Act

File Number(s):
2017-HA-001

Decision Number(s):
2017-HA-001(b)
Dr. David Kates v. Interior Health Authority

PRELIMINARY DECISION

File:
https://www.bchab.ca/app/uploads/sites/781/2020/07/2015ha002h.pdf

Date:
October 31, 2018

Act:

Hospital Act

File Number(s):
2015-HA-002

Decision Number(s):
2015-HA-002(h)
Margaret Guillen v. Island Health Authority

PRELIMINARY ISSUE OF JURISDICTION

ALLOWED

File:
https://www.bchab.ca/app/uploads/sites/781/2020/07/2017ha001a.pdf

Date:
September 26, 2018

Act:

Hospital Act

File Number(s):
2017-HA-001

Decision Number(s):
2017-HA-001(a)
Dr. Andrew Campbell v. Provincial Health Services Association

PRELIMINARY DECISION ON JURISDICTION

DISMISSED WITH LEAVE

File:
https://www.bchab.ca/app/uploads/sites/781/2020/07/2018ha002a.pdf

Date:
September 21, 2018

Act:

Hospital Act

File Number(s):
2018-HA-002

Decision Number(s):
2018-HA-002(a)
Dr. Paul Sanghera v. Vancouver Coastal Health Authority

PRELIMINARY ISSUE OF JURISDICTION

DENIED

File:
https://www.bchab.ca/app/uploads/sites/781/2020/07/2017ha002a.pdf

Date:
July 10, 2018

Act:

Hospital Act

File Number(s):
2017-HA-002

Decision Number(s):
2017-HA-002(a)
Dr. David Kates v. Interior Health Authority

PRELIMINARY DECISION

File:
https://www.bchab.ca/app/uploads/sites/781/2020/07/2015ha002g.pdf

Date:
March 22, 2018

Act:

Hospital Act

File Number(s):
2015-HA-002

Decision Number(s):
2015-HA-002(g)
Dr. Stephen Todd Sorokan v. Fraser Health Authority

FINAL DECISION

APPEAL DISMISSED

File:
https://www.bchab.ca/app/uploads/sites/781/2020/07/2014ha002b.pdf

Date:
December 19, 2017

Act:

Hospital Act

File Number(s):
2014-HA-002

Decision Number(s):
2014-HA-002(b)
Dr. Paul Sanghera v. Vancouver Coastal Health Authority

PRELIMINARY APPLICATION ON JURISDICTION

File:
https://www.bchab.ca/app/uploads/sites/781/2020/07/2017ha002_prelim_ruling.pdf

Date:
October 13, 2017

Act:

Hospital Act

File Number(s):
2017-HA-002
Dr. Michael Figurski v. Interior Health Authority

FINAL DECISION

APPEAL DISMISSED

File:
https://www.bchab.ca/app/uploads/sites/781/2020/07/2015ha001a.pdf

Date:
January 9, 2017

Act:

Hospital Act

File Number(s):
2015-HA-001

Decision Number(s):
2015-HA-001(a)
Dr. David Kates v. Interior Health Authority

FINAL DECISION

APPEAL DISMISSED

File:
https://www.bchab.ca/app/uploads/sites/781/2020/07/2015ha002f.pdf

Date:
December 5, 2016

Act:

Hospital Act

File Number(s):
2015-HA-002

Decision Number(s):
2015-HA-002(f)
Dr. David Kates v. Interior Health Authority

DECISION ON APPLICATION FOR DOCUMENT DISCLOSURE

DOCUMENT TO BE PRODUCED

File:
https://www.bchab.ca/app/uploads/sites/781/2020/07/2015ha002e.pdf

Date:
October 6, 2016

Act:

Hospital Act

File Number(s):
2015-HA-002

Decision Number(s):
2015-HA-002(e)
Dr. David Kates v. Interior Health Authority

SECOND SUPPLEMENTAL DECISION ON APPLICATIONS FOR DOCUMENT DISCLOSURE AND PARTICULARS

File:
https://www.bchab.ca/app/uploads/sites/781/2020/07/2015ha002d.pdf

Date:
October 4, 2016

Act:

Hospital Act

File Number(s):
2015-HA-002

Decision Number(s):
2015-HA-002(d)
Dr. Michael Butler v. Vancouver Coastal Health Authority

FINAL DECISION

APPEAL DISMISSED

File:
https://www.bchab.ca/app/uploads/sites/781/2020/07/2015ha003b_2016ha001a.pdf

Date:
September 29, 2016

Act:

Hospital Act

File Number(s):
2015-HA-003
2016-HA-001

Decision Number(s):
2015-HA-003(b)
2016-HA-001(a)
Dr. David Kates v. Interior Health Authority

SUPPLEMENTAL DECISION ON APPLICATIONS FOR DOCUMENT DISCLOSURE

File:
https://www.bchab.ca/app/uploads/sites/781/2020/07/2015ha002c.pdf

Date:
August 17, 2016

Act:

Hospital Act

File Number(s):
2015-HA-002

Decision Number(s):
2015-HA-002(c)
Dr. David Kates v. Interior Health Authority

DECISION ON APPLICATIONS FOR DOCUMENT DISCLOSURE AND PARTICULARS

File:
https://www.bchab.ca/app/uploads/sites/781/2020/07/2015ha002b.pdf

Date:
July 20, 2016

Act:

Hospital Act

File Number(s):
2015-HA-002

Decision Number(s):
2015-HA-002(b)
Dr. David Kates v. Interior Health Authority

DECISION ON PRELIMINARY APPLICATION

File:
https://www.bchab.ca/app/uploads/sites/781/2020/07/2015ha002a.pdf

Date:
May 25, 2016

Act:

Hospital Act

File Number(s):
2015-HA-002

Decision Number(s):
2015-HA-002(a)
Dr. Michael Butler v. Vancouver Coastal Health Authority

PRELIMINARY APPLICATION TO DISMISS APPEAL

DISMISSED WITH CONDITIONS

File:
https://www.bchab.ca/app/uploads/sites/781/2020/07/2015ha003a.pdf

Date:
December 9, 2015

Act:

Hospital Act

File Number(s):
2015-HA-003

Decision Number(s):
2015-HA-003(a)
Dr. Stephen Todd Sorokan v. Fraser Health Authority

PRELIMINARY DECISION ON TIMING FOR DETERMINING JURISDICTION

DENIED

File:
https://www.bchab.ca/app/uploads/sites/781/2020/07/2014ha002a.pdf

Date:
June 30, 2015

Act:

Hospital Act

File Number(s):
2014-HA-002

Decision Number(s):
2014-HA-002(a)
Dr. Randy Walker v. Fraser Health Authority

FINAL DECISION

APPEAL GRANTED

File:
https://www.bchab.ca/app/uploads/sites/781/2020/07/2013ha003a.pdf

Date:
June 9, 2014

Act:

Hospital Act

File Number(s):
2013-HA-003

Decision Number(s):
2013-HA-003(a)
Dr. Tracy Hicks v. Fraser Health Authority, operating as Peace Arch Hospital

FINAL DECISION

APPEAL DISMISSED

File:
https://www.bchab.ca/app/uploads/sites/781/2020/07/hicks_2013.pdf

Date:
June 17, 2013

Act:

Hospital Act
Dr. Tracy Eugene Hicks v. Fraser Health Authority (operating as Peace Arch Hospital)

PRELIMINARY DECISION ON PROCEDURE FOR DETERMINING JURISDICTION

DENIED

File:
https://www.bchab.ca/app/uploads/sites/781/2020/07/hab_hicks_prelim.pdf

Date:
May 11, 2011

Act:

Hospital Act

File Number(s):
2011-HAB-001
Dr. Darren Behn v. Vancouver Island Health Authority

APPLICATION FOR COSTS

DISMISSED

File:
https://www.bchab.ca/app/uploads/sites/781/2020/07/behn_costs_2010.pdf

Date:
December 31, 2010

Act:

Hospital Act
Dr. Darren Behn v. Vancouver Island Health Authority

FINAL DECISION

APPEAL ALLOWED

Date:
May 19, 2010

Act:

Hospital Act
Dr. C v. X, a Health Authority

INTERIM STAY APPLICATION

DENIED

File:
https://www.bchab.ca/app/uploads/sites/781/2020/07/dr_c_2009.pdf

Date:
June 5, 2009

Act:

Hospital Act
Joanne Daviau v. St. Joseph’s Hospital

STAY DECISION

GRANTED WITH CONDITIONS

File:
https://www.bchab.ca/app/uploads/sites/781/2020/07/hab_joanne_daviau.pdf

Date:
June 10, 2008

Act:

Hospital Act
Dr. Imran Samad v. Provincial Health Services Authority and The Children’s and Women’s Health Centre of BC

PRELIMINARY DECISION OF DISCLOSURE OF DOCUMENTS

GRANTED WITH CONDITIONS

File:
https://www.bchab.ca/app/uploads/sites/781/2020/07/hab_imran_samad.pdf

Date:
July 27, 2007

Act:

Hospital Act
Dr. Timothy Ng v. Richmond Health Services Society

FINAL DECISION

APPEAL DISMISSED

File:
https://www.bchab.ca/app/uploads/sites/781/2020/07/timothy_ng_2003.pdf

Date:
February 6, 2003

Act:

Hospital Act
Dr. Timothy Ng v. Richmond Health Services Society (now Vancouver Coastal Health Authority)

PRELIMINARY DECISION OF ADMISSIBILITY OF EVIDENCE

DENIED

File:
https://www.bchab.ca/app/uploads/sites/781/2020/07/hab_timothy_ng.pdf

Date:
November 27, 2002

Act:

Hospital Act
Dr. W. R. Eric Jamieson v. St. Paul’s Hospital

PRELIMINARY DECISION OF ADMISSIBILITY OF EVIDENCE

File:
https://www.bchab.ca/app/uploads/sites/781/2020/07/hab_eric_jamieson.pdf

Date:
August 2, 2002

Act:

Hospital Act
Dr. Timothy Ng v. Richmond Health Services Society (now Vancouver Coastal Health Authority)

PRELIMINARY DECISION OF ADMISSIBILITY OF EVIDENCE

File:
https://www.bchab.ca/app/uploads/sites/781/2020/07/hab_timothy_ng_2.pdf

Date:
June 10, 2002

Act:

Hospital Act
Dr. Kenneth Fung v. South Fraser Health Region

FINAL DECISION

APPEAL UPHELD

File:
https://www.bchab.ca/app/uploads/sites/781/2020/07/kenneth_fung_2001.pdf

Date:
February 27, 2001

Act:

Hospital Act
Dr. David R. Ellis v. Central Vancouver Island Health Region

PRELIMINARY DECISON OF INTERIM RELIEF

DENIED

File:
https://www.bchab.ca/app/uploads/sites/781/2020/07/hab_david_ellis.pdf

Date:
January 19, 2001

Act:

Hospital Act
Dr. Ian Munro v. The St. Paul’s Hospital

FINAL DECISION

File:
https://www.bchab.ca/app/uploads/sites/781/2020/07/ian_munro_2000.pdf

Date:
December 22, 2000

Act:

Hospital Act
Dr. Donna Cuthbert v. Capital Health Region

FINAL DECISION

File:
https://www.bchab.ca/app/uploads/sites/781/2020/07/donna_cuthbert_2000.pdf

Date:
November 15, 2000

Act:

Hospital Act
Dr. Vinod C. Tawar v. Mission Memorial Hospital

FINAL DECISION

APPEAL DENIED

File:
https://www.bchab.ca/app/uploads/sites/781/2020/07/vinod_tawar_1997.pdf

Date:
December 16, 1997

Act:

Hospital Act
Dr. Munwar M. Sabir v. Matsqui-Sumas-Abbotsford Hospital

FINAL DECISION

APPEAL DISMISSED

File:
https://www.bchab.ca/app/uploads/sites/781/2020/07/munwar_sabir_1997.pdf

Date:
October 28, 1997

Act:

Hospital Act

Preliminary and Final Decisions

Acts