BC Hospital Appeal Board
Skip to navigation Skip to Contents Skip to Accessibility Statement
Home Preliminary and Final Decisions
Search Menu
About the Board Board Members Annual Reports and Board Remuneration Career Opportunities Appeal Process Rules and Practice Directives Prepare for a Hearing HAB appeal decisions Judicial Review decisions Legislation and Regulations Additional Resources Frequently Asked Questions

Preliminary and Final Decisions

File Number
Appeal Name
Act
Date Issued
Decision Number

HAB-HA-20-A001

Katherine Puchala v. Northern Health Authority

[POST-DECISION APPLICATION TO VARY ORDER - Granted in Part]
HAB-HA-20-A001d
March 15, 2023

HAB-HA-20-A001(d)

HAB-HA-22-A002

February 3, 2023

HAB-HA-22-A002(a)

HAB-HA-20-A003

December 7, 2022

HAB-HA-20-A003(b)

HAB-HA-22-A001

Dr. Saraswathi Vedam v. Provincial Health Services Authority

[APPLICATION FOR INTERIM STAY - GRANTED; CORRIGENDUM ADDED]
HAB-HA-22-A001a_corrigendum
July 26, 2022

HAB-HA-22-A001(a)

HAB-HA-20-A001

March 16, 2022

HAB-HA-20-A001(c)

HAB-HA-20-A003

Dr. Malvinder Hoonjan v. Interior Health Authority

[APPLICATION FOR DOCUMENT PRODUCTION - GRANTED]
HAB-HA-20-A003a
February 15, 2022

HAB-HA-20-A003(a)

HAB-HA-20-A001

Katherine Puchala v. Northern Health Authority

[APPLICATION FOR ADJOURNMENT - HEARING ADJOURNED]
HAB-HA-20-A001b
February 24, 2021

HAB-HA-20-A001(b)

2019-HA-001

Dr. Francis McCormack v. Island Health Authority

[PRELIMINARY APPLICATIONS - GRANTED IN PART]
February 5, 2021

2019-HA-001(a)

HAB-HA-20-A001

Katherine Puchala v. Northern Health Authority

[PRELIMINARY DECISION - APPLICATIONS DISMISSED]
HAB-HA-20-A001a
February 2, 2021

HAB-HA-20-A001(a)

2018-HA-002

August 20, 2020

2018-HA-002(f)

2018-HA-002

Dr. Campbell v. Provincial Health Services Authority

[DECISION ON REASONABLE APPREHENSION OF BIAS - DISMISSED]
2018-HA-002e
June 16, 2020

2018-HA-002(e)

2018-HA-002

Dr. Andrew Campbell v. Provincial Health Services Authority

[APPLICATION FOR INTERIM INJUCTIVE RELIEF - DISMISSED]
2018ha002d
July 11, 2019

2018-HA-002(d)

2015-HA-002

Dr. David Kates v. Interior Health Authority

[POSTHEARING DECISION - NO JURISDICTION TO GRANT ORDER REQUESTED]
2015ha002_clarification_ruling
December 20, 2018

2018-HA-002

Dr. Andrew Campbell v. Provincial Health Services Authority

[PRELIMINARY DECISION ON STAY APPLICATION - DISMISSED]
2018ha002b
November 30, 2018

2018-HA-002(b)

2017-HA-001

Margaret Guillen v. Island Health Authority

[PRELIMINARY DECISION - SCOPE OF REMEDY]
2017ha001b
November 16, 2018

2017-HA-001(b)

2015-HA-002

Dr. David Kates v. Interior Health Authority

[POSTHEARING DECISION - CLARIFICATION ON IMPLEMENTATION ORDER]
2015ha002h
October 31, 2018

2015-HA-002(h)

2017-HA-001

Margaret Guillen v. Island Health Authority

[PRELIMINARY ISSUE OF JURISDICTION - ALLOWED]
2017ha001a
September 26, 2018

2017-HA-001(a)

2018-HA-002

Dr. Andrew Campbell v. Provincial Health Services Association

[PRELIMINARY DECISION ON JURISDICTION - DISMISSED WITH LEAVE]
2018ha002a
September 21, 2018

2018-HA-002(a)

2017-HA-002

Dr. Paul Sanghera v. Vancouver Coastal Health Authority

[PRELIMINARY ISSUE OF JURISDICTION - DENIED]
2017ha002a
July 10, 2018

2017-HA-002(a)

2015-HA-002

Dr. David Kates v. Interior Health Authority

[POSTHEARING DECISION - CLARIFICATION ON IMPLEMENTATION ORDER]
2015ha002g
March 22, 2018

2015-HA-002(g)

2014-HA-002

December 19, 2017

2014-HA-002(b)

2017-HA-002

Dr. Paul Sanghera v. Vancouver Coastal Health Authority

[PRELIMINARY - RULING ON APPLICATION FOR STANDING (ISSUE OF JURISDICTION)]
2017ha002_prelim_ruling
October 13, 2017

2015-HA-001

January 9, 2017

2015-HA-001(a)

2015-HA-002

December 5, 2016

2015-HA-002(f)

2015-HA-002

Dr. David Kates v. Interior Health Authority

[DECISION ON APPLICATION FOR DOCUMENT DISCLOSURE - DOCUMENT TO BE PRODUCED]
[EXTENSION OF TIME TO FILE AND EXPERT REPORT - GRANTED]
2015ha002e
October 6, 2016

2015-HA-002(e)